We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (2024)

What We Like

  • Affordable

  • Easy to use and care for

  • Retains heat well

What We Don't Like

  • Heavy

Lodge Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven Review

This porcelain-enameled cast-iron Dutch oven from Lodge comes in a variety of exterior colors, with a cream-colored interior for excellent visibility, similar to many higher-end versions. Due to the double layer of enamel coating inside and out, this can be used for marinating, cooking, storing, and serving.In addition to the colorful enamel, the modern design gives you wider handles, which make it easier to grip when you have oven mitts on. This is helpful as it is heavy.

The pot is oven-safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit for baking or broiling and the different size options hold anywhere from 1.5 to 3, 4.5, 6, or 7.5 quarts. We've tested multiple of these and found the tight-fitting lid helped retain moisture during cooking. We also gave the Lodge high marks for how well it distributed and retained heat. After cooking a pot full of chicken tagine, the Lodge pot stayed hot for hours. We also noted that whether we browned chicken thighs or cooked onions with spices, any stuck-on bits loosened easily with a little bit of liquid.

Overall, we were pleasantly surprised that this model performed just as well as its more expensive competitors. It can be used on any cooktop, including gas, electric, or induction, but it shouldn’t be used on outdoor grills or over campfires. While handwashing is recommended, it can be washed in a dishwasher.

Material: Enameled cast iron | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees Fahrenheit | Dishwasher Safe: Yes, but hand washing is recommended | Available Sizes: 1.5, 3, 4.5, 6, and 7.5 quarts

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (2)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (3)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (4)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (5)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (6)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (7)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (8)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (9)

What We Like

  • Retains and distributes heat well

  • Versatile

  • Inimitable design adds flair to your kitchen

What We Don't Like

  • Steep price point

  • Resin knob is only oven-safe up to 500 degrees

Le Creuset Signature Round Dutch Oven Review

The Le Creuset Dutch oven exceeded our expectations in terms of heat distribution and retention—the pot’s high sides and heat-conducting properties made evenly browning a whole chicken a cinch. We also tested the 7.5-quart model, which (aside from its larger size) shares all the same attributes as this 5.5-quart version. During testing, we found that the thick cast iron base took a few minutes to heat up, but once it did, it stayed hot. Plus, our tests further confirmed its excellent performance—on the stove, chicken thighs browned evenly and released easily, and food that spent a bit of time in the oven didn't stick either.

We found that the enameled surface sustained a little bit of crazing—a network of fine lines or cracks that might appear—with repeated impact with metal utensils. But, it's good to note that this is a common occurrence with enameled cast iron, and typically doesn't impact its performance. Cleaning this Dutch oven by hand is easy, but it is also dishwasher safe.

This Le Creuset pot is an all-time favorite but, like all of its cookware, comes with a steep price point. If you are looking for a larger size or prefer an oval shape, Le Creuset has those as well. The Le Creuset Dutch ovens come in a wide variety of colors to coordinate with anyone’s kitchen décor but be on the lookout for new and seasonal releases. While Le Creuset's Dutch ovens are oven safe to 500 degrees, its black phenolic knobs are not. If you need to cook at an even higher temperature, you can buy a replacement metal knob.

Material: Enameled cast iron | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees Fahrenheit | Dishwasher Safe: Yes | Available Sizes: 1, 2, 2.75, 3.5, 4.5, 5.5, 7.25, 9, and 13.25 quarts

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (11)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (12)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (13)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (14)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (15)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (16)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (17)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (18)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (19)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (20)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (21)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (22)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (23)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (24)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (25)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (26)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (27)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (28)

What We Don't Like

  • Must be hand-washed

  • Handles get hot during cooking

Lodge Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven Review

This raw cast-iron Dutch oven comes pre-seasoned to give you a head start on getting a perfectly nonstick pot. But that’s not the best part: the lid of this Dutch oven doubles as a skillet with two side handles, so you get two pots in one for an incredibly low price. You'll be able to simmer your soup in the pot and make cornbread in the skillet at the same time. We found the skillet also worked wonderfully to do double batches at once, like when browning meat. Once we did an extra round of seasoning, even cinnamon rolls came right out without leaving a crumb behind.

We tested the 7-quart model of this pan and found that it worked beautifully to brown chicken, with crisp edges and very minimal sticking. Cooking rice also turned out great, with no sticking or hot spots detected. We also noted that it can be used with metal utensils and stand up to fairly rough handling without any sign of damage—it's a piece that can certainly be handed down well into the future.

The downside of the skillet feature is that the lid doesn’t have a top handle for lifting, and the handles do get very hot when in use. Raw cast-iron cookware is safe for use at any oven temperature as well as on an outdoor grill or campfire. At super-high temperatures, the seasoning can burn off, but it won’t hurt the cookware, you would just need to season it again. This would make a great, affordable gift for a cook of any skill level as it is easy to use and will last for years to come.

Material: Seasoned cast iron | Oven Safe Temperature: 500+ degrees Fahrenheit | Dishwasher Safe: No | Available Sizes: 5 and 6 quarts

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (30)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (31)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (32)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (33)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (34)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (35)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (36)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (37)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (38)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (39)

What We Like

  • Excellent nonstick performance

  • Even heating

  • Available in many color options

What We Don't Like

  • Hand wash only

For a budget pick, this 5-quart model by Crock Pot performs well above its modest price point. The cast iron build gives the oven heft so it doesn't move on the stovetop and also offers even heat distribution and retention. The lid's texture gives it a self-basting feature, allowing condensation to collect and redistribute itself over whatever is cooking so it doesn't dry out. Oversized handles make it easy to grab with pot holders on, and the metal knob and Dutch oven are oven-safe to 500 degrees.

We were able to achieve consistent and even browning with a nice crust on chicken thighs, though we did find the cooking surface to be on the small side—not a deal-breaker if you're okay with browning in batches. When it came to cooking rice, it didn't stick or burn when left to simmer and steam, and all liquid was completely absorbed.

It was hard to find any major flaws with this oven. Like many enameled versions, using a metal utensil may leave scratches on the inner enamel, and you'll have to be careful not to crack the outer coating with rough handling. The manufacturer highly recommends hand washing it to clean, which is pretty easy.

Material: Enameled cast iron | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees Fahrenheit | Dishwasher Safe: No | Available Sizes: 3, 5, and 7 quarts

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (41)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (42)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (43)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (44)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (45)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (46)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (47)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (48)

What We Like

  • Even heat distribution and retention

  • Interior nubs allows for self-basting

  • Pot can handle 900 degrees

What We Don't Like

  • Very heavy

  • Dark interior makes it hard to see fond development

  • Expensive

Staub Cast Iron 6-Quart Round Cocotte Review

This Staub cocotte is wider and slightly shallower than other pots of the same size, while still holding a generous amount of food. It also has a black interior that is less likely to show food stains. The heavy lid keeps the vessel well-sealed, and nubs on the interior of the lid send moisture raining down on the food for self-basting.

We found it to be jaw-droppingly good at everything it does, and especially love its performance as a bread baking chamber and vessel for cooking beans and stews. Our tests showed even, deep brown caramelization when searing chicken thighs, demonstrating even heat distribution and no hot spots. Rice cooked perfectly, just shy of al dente, and it didn't stick or burn when left to steam with the lid closed. (Note: We tested the Staub 5.5-quart round cocotte, which is made nearly identically to the 6-quart shallow cocotte in materials and construction.)

We didn't notice any markings or damage with use, though enamel always has the potential to crack or chip on impact. While the price point on this model is on the high side, its performance and durability live up to what you'd expect for a Dutch oven of this caliber. Additionally, the lid is oven-safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, while the pot can handle up to 900 degrees. It's easy to clean—though the dark interior requires that you inspect it closely to ensure it's free of debris—and promises decades, if not a lifetime, of use.

Material: Enameled cast iron | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees Fahrenheit (with lid), 900 degrees Fahrenheit (without lid) | Dishwasher Safe: Yes, but hand washing is recommended | Available Sizes: 6 quarts

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (50)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (51)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (52)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (53)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (54)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (55)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (56)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (57)

What We Like

  • Self-basting lid

  • Even heat distribution

  • Reasonably priced

  • Accessories included

What We Don't Like

  • Hand wash only

  • Lid rim susceptible to rust

The Our Place enamel-coated cast-iron Perfect Pot is ready to use as soon as it arrives, of course, after a quick scrub with soap and water. With a 5.5-quart capacity, the pot is a good size to cook meals for the family but it's not so big that it becomes cumbersome to use.

We love to test any Dutch oven by making a batch of caramelized onions to check whether we can get any solid caramelization without using a cartouche (a lid made of parchment paper). Not only did this pot make an impressive batch, it was also great for browning meat and chicken, with all our tests displaying even heat distribution. The interior of the lid is spiked, which enables the steam to turn into condensation and keep your food moist. We found it was not necessary to stir food often when the lid was on because of the retained moisture. Plus, the cast iron held onto the heat, and kept food warm for at least an hour after cooking.

We also used the pot for making crusty loaves of bread. It was challenging to place dough directly in the Perfect Pot, but, when used as a part of a makeshift bread oven with the Our Place grill pan, it was much easier to load up the dough due to the pan’s low height. The bread baked beautifully though, whichever way we made it.

To preserve the enamel, the pot needs to be hand-washed, and it also needs to be dried immediately. At least, the lid needs to be dried immediately. We noticed a circular rust ring on the countertop after leaving the lid on it for a few hours post-washing.

Material: Enameled cast iron | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees Fahrenheit | Dishwasher Safe: No | Available Capacity: 5.5 Quarts

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (59)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (60)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (61)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (62)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (63)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (64)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (65)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (66)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (67)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (68)

What We Like

  • Heat safe to over 500 degrees

  • Lifetime warranty

  • Extra-large loop handles

What We Don't Like

  • Carrier is a separate purchase

This enameled cast-iron Dutch oven has features we like for baking bread—a metal knob that won’t be bothered by oven heat, a wide flat bottom for a good crust, and the ability to withstand heat over 500 degrees Fahrenheit. With all that, it still has an affordable price tag that leaves some money to pay for fancy flours, add-ins, and tasty toppings.

But of course, a good Dutch oven can be used in a multitude of ways, so we tested this model with non-bread tasks. It has a generously sized cooking surface where we were able to sear chicken without sticking. We did find that browning results weren't as even as with other models we tested, but it did cook rice perfectly with no sticking or scorching. The white interior makes it easier to monitor the browning process and see the fond (aka the caramelized brown bits) develop in the bottom of the pot. During our durability tests, we noticed a little bit of chipping of the external paint after impact, but that won't affect its usability.

Marquette Castings designed this with extra-large loop handles for an easy grip, even when wearing your favorite oven mitts. Available separately is a carrying bag that makes it easy to bring a hot pot—even directly from the oven—to a potluck or party.

Material: Enameled cast iron | Oven Safe Temperature: 500 degrees Fahrenheit | Dishwasher Safe: No | Available Sizes: 4 and 6 quarts

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (70)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (71)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (72)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (73)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (74)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (75)

What We Like

  • Lighter than cast iron

  • Microwave safe, freezer and oven safe

  • Oven safe to 700 degrees

What We Don't Like

  • Doesn't heat as evenly as cast iron

  • Not induction compatible

  • Prone to breakage

If you're searching for a Dutch oven that isn't so heavy, you may want to opt for a ceramic version. Made of high-fired Burgundian clay, this model by Emile Henry can handle temperatures up to 930 degrees and can go nearly anywhere a cast iron Dutch oven can go. Use it on the stovetop, on a grill, or in the oven—it can even be used in the microwave (it doesn't work with induction, though). The glaze—not enamel—is scratch-resistant and you'll find drip points inside the lid to keep your food from drying out.

When choosing a ceramic Dutch oven, it's important to note that it will inevitably perform very differently from cast iron versions, simply due to its materials. We tested the 7.5-quart Emile Henry model and found that it does not heat as evenly as cast iron, resulting in hotter outer edges and a slightly cooler surface towards the center. That being said, we were still able to create browned chicken thighs and evenly cooked rice with little trouble. We also noted it is much more susceptible to breakage—handle it with care, since one drop or heavy impact can potentially crack it and render it useless.

This Dutch oven can be easily cleaned by hand or sent through the dishwasher. Emile Henry backs this with a 10-year warranty should it have any production or quality defects.

Material: Ceramic | Oven Safe Temperature: 700+ degrees | Dishwasher Safe: Yes | Available Sizes: 4, 6, 7.5 quarts

We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (77)

What We Like

  • Flanged lid to hold coals on top

  • Lid doubles as a griddle or trivet

  • Opening in the rim for thermometer

What We Don't Like

  • Can’t be used on all heat sources

Camp Chef Classic Dutch Oven Review

Heading for the great outdoors? This camp-style uncoated cast-iron Dutch oven will help you cook up anything your nature-loving heart desires. It's designed with feet to raise it over hot coals, plus you can place coals atop the flat, tight-fitting lid for even heating inside. Best of all, this arrives pre-seasoned, so you can pack it for your trip as soon as it arrives, but the coating will improve with additional seasoning and use.

This 6-quart Dutch oven is a truly versatile piece of cookware—you can also flip the lid over to use it as a skillet or griddle. In fact, we did just that, warming up tortillas and frying eggs directly on the lid for a perfect outdoor breakfast. Don't be nervous if you're not well-versed in using coals to set the temperature—neither were we—as this comes with a guide with charcoal distribution guidelines. Once we got the hang of where to place coals, we were able to whip up shakshuka and cheesy enchiladas with ease.

One thing to note is that this is undeniably better for outdoor cooking. While this is oven-safe, it might be awkward to place inside of one due to the legs. It might work on a gas cooktop, depending on your stove grates, but it is not recommended for an electric or induction cooktop.

Material: Seasoned cast iron | Oven Safe Temperature: 500+ degrees Fahrenheit | Dishwasher Safe: No | Available Sizes: 10, 12, 14, and 16 inches

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (79)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (80)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (81)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (82)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (83)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (84)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (85)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (86)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (87)

  • We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (88)

Final Verdict

Our top choice is the Lodge Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven because everyday cooks can still enjoy a highly functional, versatile pot; plus, it's easy to clean. If you're looking for a future heirloom, we love the Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron 5.5-Quart Round Dutch Oven.

We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (89)

Other Options We Tested

  • Great Jones The Dutchess: A previous version of this roundup included the oval-shaped model called The Dutchess by Great Jones. We noticed some hot spots when using this Dutch oven on the stove due to its long shape, despite the fact that cast iron should distribute heat fairly evenly. Another concern was that the stylish copper loop handle proved difficult to grab when wearing oven mitts, creating a slightly precarious situation when checking on a braise. Though it's reasonably priced and certainly very attractive, ultimately, we found that there are better options available.
  • Amazon Basics 6-Quart Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven: This popular budget option performed well, but our Lab tests made us question its durability in the long run. We noticed some minor cosmetic scratches after cooking with metal utensils, so we caution buyers to use a wooden spoon whenever possible.
  • Denby Natural Canvas Cast Iron: This seemed like a great, budget-friendly model for beginners, but our Lab tests found a few pain points. It's got a pretty small cooking surface, so you'd have to batch-cook large amounts of proteins. We also noticed some durability issues with the enamel—while it doesn't affect the oven's functionality, we feel there are better options out there at a similar price point.

What to Look For When Buying a Dutch Oven

Material

Dutch ovens are most often made of cast iron, whether enameled or not. But you can also find these pots in ceramic, stainless steel, and aluminum varieties. As we'll discuss later, the material impacts everything from heating capacity and reactivity to durability, weight, and maintenance.

Size

Dutch ovens can be found in sizes as small as 1/4-quart (perfect for individual servings of French onion soup or cobbler) and as large as 13-quart, great for large batches of chili or braising pork belly for a crowd. For most households, a 5- to 7-quart is the most popular: it’s large enough to hold a whole chicken or bake a 2-pound loaf of bread, and depending on what you're cooking, it can easily feed a family of four with leftovers. When selecting the size for your oven, it’s better to have one that’s too big rather than too small. It’s much easier to cook a small amount in a big pot than to have a smaller pot filled to the brim. Also, consider that a Dutch oven can be quite bulky;you will want to make sure you have adequate storage space for whatever size you choose.

Shape

The two most common shapes for Dutch ovens are round and oval. Round is the most popular shape: it sits well on a single burner for even heating, is often deeper, and the shape also lends itself well to smooth stirring. An oval-shaped oven is usually shallower and wider than round versions; it's ideal for cooking longer cuts of meat in the oven. On the stovetop, an oval shape doesn’t distribute heat as evenly as round ovens, but you’ll barely notice a difference if you preheat it in the oven before use.

Features

A Dutch oven’s lid and handle design are very important. First, well-fitting lids will help keep meats from drying out and keep stews and sauces from evaporating too quickly. Most ovens will come with a lid in the same material as the rest of the vessel, but you may find a Dutch oven with a tempered glass lid that allows you to visually monitor your food. The shape of the lid is a matter of preference; domed lids with smooth interiors will send moisture back down the sides of the oven, while flatter lids with bumps or ridges on the inside offer a self-basting feature by redirecting any condensation directly down into the pot.

While Dutch ovens are typically oven-proof, the lid’s handle, or knob, may have a heat threshold below 400 degrees Fahrenheit (like Le Creuset’s classic black polymer knob). These non-metal knobs that are heated beyond their limit will crack and make a hot lid difficult to remove. You can buy an oven-proof replacement knob in stainless steel and switch them out yourself, or simply select a model that already has a metal knob or handle that can withstand higher temperatures.

Since the entire Dutch oven will heat up when it is in use, it’s important that the handles are easy to hold without the risk of getting burned. Loop handles on the sides of the vessel should be wide enough to hold even while wearing potholders, and secure enough that they won’t crack or bend when carrying a heavy pot filled with soup or braised meat. Camping-style ovens will often use a wire bail handle, useful for hanging over an open fire or lifting to turn and adjust atop hot coals. Ensure that the wire handle is made of galvanized tempered steel and is sturdy enough to carry the weight of the pot and its contents without breaking.

Heating Capacity

Traditional uncoated cast iron ovens are built to withstand use on any cooktop, as well as an open flame. Bare cast iron can typically handle over 500 degrees Fahrenheit; high-fired ceramic is rated to about 500 degrees Fahrenheit; enameled cast iron can be heated to around 450 degrees Fahrenheit before it could start to damage the enamel coating. Stainless steel and cast aluminum should be used at medium and lower temperatures. Always refer to the manufacturer’s guide for your Dutch oven’s specific maximum heat limit.

Maintenance

Dutch ovens are usually constructed of thick metal and hold up well to daily use, but they are not completely impervious to damage. Taking proper care of your cocotte will help preserve the longevity of this essential piece of cookware.

If your oven is made of bare cast iron, you will need to maintain its seasoning in order to protect it from rust and corrosion and to keep its nonstick properties. Be sure to scrub any food particles away without any additional cleaning agents, as soaps and detergents will remove any existing seasoning. Once the surface is smooth and free of any debris, wipe it clean, and lightly oil the inside of the vessel. You will want to heat the Dutch oven on high (about 400 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit) to reseason the pan, let it cool, and then put it away for future use.

Enameled cast iron pieces do not need the same care; the enamel coating will serve as its seasoning, giving it a rust-resistant, nonstick finish. Lighter-colored enamel may show some staining after simmering dark sauces, but it can usually be removed with a light scrub with a non-abrasive scouring pad. For stubborn stains, either use a 1:2 paste of vinegar and baking soda or Bar Keepers Friend. Enameled cast iron pieces can also be put into the dishwasher for easy cleaning.

The care for cast aluminum, stainless steel, and ceramic cookware is similar. For cast aluminum and stainless steel, you will want to let the vessel cool completely before coming into contact with cool water to avoid thermal shock. All three of these can be scrubbed with a nylon scouring pad and dish soap, or put into the dishwasher for cleaning (unless the manufacturer says otherwise).

Warranty

Many major manufacturers offer some warranty against defects in material and workmanship. Le Creuset and Lodge offer a limited lifetime warranty, with other brands like Emile Henry and Staub giving anywhere from a 10- to 30-year warranty.These guarantees may exclude damage arising from improper use, thermal shocks, drops, or normal wear and tear, and can also be void if used in a commercial kitchen. Before you buy, be sure to check on the manufacturer’s terms and warranty coverage to make sure it’s what you need.

We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (90)

Types of Dutch Ovens

Cast Iron

This is the material of choice for the top-rated Dutch oven brands, due to its ability to retain and distribute heat. Not only is cast iron highly durable, but it is also suitable for use on almost any cooktop (including induction), and directly over open fires such as atop a barbecue grill or over a campfire. Each time you use a cast iron pot, you continue to season it, improving its surface. However, it is not ideal for acidic dishes, since acids can react badly with the pan’s material and can sometimes cause "off" flavors. Bare cast iron pots require some maintenance: they need to be hand-washed without detergents (which can remove the seasoning) and re-oiled before storing. With proper care, these pots can last virtually forever.

Enameled Cast Iron

This is a very popular material for Dutch ovens, bringing an element of rustic European design to your kitchen. These ovens are made of cast iron that has a glass-like enamel coating bonded to the metal, which helps to prevent rusting and also eliminates the need for seasoning its surface. This material is ideal for all types of food because it is non-reactive, unlike bare cast iron. This type of cookware is also suitable for a variety of cooktops, including induction. Lighter enameled interiors are more prone to visible stains, but these can be removed with a non-abrasive cleaner like Bar Keepers Friend, as well as gentle scrubbing.

Ceramic

This type of cookware tends to be more affordable than enameled cast iron but boasts a similarly pleasing aesthetic for your kitchen. Made of high-fired clay, these pieces are also PFOA- and PTFE-free, non-reactive, and resistant to thermal shock.However, they are more prone to chipping and breakage than cast iron ovens. Look for a ceramic Dutch oven that is suitable for use on the stove (with an induction disc if you need it), because not all ceramic cookware is designed to withstand direct heat. The gentle heating properties of ceramic make it ideal for slow cooking and enhancing flavor. Most ceramic Dutch ovens are oven-safe up to about 500 degrees and simple to clean by handwashing or placing into the dishwasher.

Stainless Steel

While traditional Dutch ovens are made of cast iron, there are also Dutch oven-shaped vessels made of stainless steel, a durable, non-reactive material that is commonly used for cookware. Well-constructed stainless steel Dutch ovens stand up well to daily use and are easy to maintain. However, they will not hold heat as well as their cast iron counterparts. Regardless, these pots are ideal for someone who doesn’t want to deal with lifting heavy cookware in and out of storage or from the stove to the oven.

Cast Aluminum

This is another excellent option for a Dutch oven that is lighter than cast iron. These ovens are made by casting molten aluminum in a mold, creating a hard and durable oven that is non-reactive and less susceptible to warping or damage.Cast aluminum also can be used on electric and gas stovetops and in the oven, has better heat conductivity than stainless steel, and is naturally nonstick. This material is generally very low-maintenance because it can be soaked and washed in the dishwasher and doesn’t need to be seasoned to maintain its surface.

We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (91)

Brands

Le Creuset

Likely the most iconic Dutch oven brand, Le Creuset was founded in 1925 in northern France by two Belgian industrialists who combined their casting and enameling skills to create the signature Le Creuset cocotte. The brand currently manufactures enameled cast iron braisers, grill pans, and skillets in a variety of colors, and has also expanded its product offerings with stainless steel cookware and stoneware casseroles. Le Creuset cocottes are still made in France today and are often considered heritage pieces that can be handed down through generations because of their superior durability.

Staub

This brand is a premium enameled cast iron cookware manufacturer founded in Alsace, France. Its signature French-made cocotte is made of cast iron and double-glazed with durable enamel, making it rust-proof and easy to clean. Staub’s design includes a flat lid featuring nubs on the interior that allow condensation to form and drip down to baste whatever is cooking in the pot. Staub also produces a variety of ceramic bowls, baking dishes, and oven-only cocottes in addition to an extensive line of enameled and non-enameled cast iron pieces.

Lodge

As the oldest and longest-running cast iron manufacturer in the U.S., Lodge has built a solid reputation for its uncoated cast iron skillets but it also manufactures griddles, grill pans, woks, and more. Its uncoated Dutch ovens are perfect for stovetop or camping use and are very affordable and long-lasting. Like other companies, Lodge has expanded its product lines and now also sells enameled cast iron cookware. While the uncoated cast iron pans are manufactured in the U.S., its other products may be manufactured elsewhere.

IMUSA

Founded in Colombia, IMUSA is the leading supplier of Latin cookware across South, Central, and most recently North America, primarily to prepare Hispanic foods. The company’s biggest seller is the caldero ("cauldron" in English), a cast-aluminum Dutch oven that serves as an all-purpose pot for making rice, soups, and stews, and braising meats. Its line of kitchen goods also includes stainless steel, ceramic, cast iron, and carbon steel cookware, as well as an array of kitchen gadgets and small appliances at a very affordable price point.

Emile Henry

This French-based company has been making fine ceramic ovenware and bakeware since 1850. Its Dutch ovens are made from Burgundian clay, which gradually and evenly distributes heat to the center of the cooking vessel. The Flame ceramic pieces (which include Dutch ovens, tagines, bread pots, fondue pots, and more) are glazed and high-fired, do not contain lead or cadmium, and can go from the freezer to the microwave or oven without risk of thermal shock. The Dutch oven can also be used on all stovetops—including induction ranges, thanks to an induction disc—as well as directly on the barbecue grill.

We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (92)

FAQs

How do you use a Dutch oven?

Dutch ovens are prized for their versatility, so your options are pretty wide. You can use most Dutch ovens right on the stove, in the oven, and (depending on their finish) over open fires and atop barbecue grills.

What can you make in a Dutch oven?

Since Dutch ovens have the ability to maintain even heat for a long amount of time, they're ideal for cooking long-simmering stews, soups, braised meats, and even acting as a baking chamber for bread. If you're just getting started, try your hand at this impressive yet easy recipe for beef bourguignon or a classic pot roast. If you've never baked bread in your Dutch oven before, try this no-knead loaf (just be sure your vessel's heat threshold is high enough).

What size Dutch oven is best for making bread?

Dutch ovens between 5 and 7.5 quarts should be enough for a standard single loaf recipe.

Can you boil water in a Dutch oven?

Yes. Cast iron does heat up slowly, so it may not come to a boil as quickly as it would in an aluminum or stainless steel pan, but it can be done.

Can you deep fry in a Dutch oven?

Yes. Thanks to cast iron's ability to hold a constant temperature, plus the depth of the Dutch oven silhouette, it's an excellent vessel for deep frying.

Why use a Dutch oven over other cookware?

One word: versatility. It lends itself well to a variety of cooking styles and can go from stovetop to oven with ease. Its durable construction will help it stand up to frequent use, and most Dutch ovens are attractive enough to act as a serving dish, too, adding a touch of rustic elegance to the table.

Can you put a Dutch oven in the dishwasher?

It depends. Most enameled cast iron-type ovens can go into the dishwasher, but because they tend to take up a lot of space, you might find it easier to hand wash them instead. Non-enameled (aka "raw" or "bare") cast iron should not be put into the dishwasher, as the water and detergent will strip away its seasoning. For more details on caring for raw cast iron, check out this guide.

Can you put a cold Dutch oven in the oven?

Rapid changes in heat can potentially damage cast iron, causing it to crack. If your Dutch oven is cold (as in, it was in the refrigerator), you will want to let it come to room temperature or gently heat it up on the stove before putting it in a hot oven. You can put a cold/room temperature Dutch oven into a cold oven and let them preheat at the same time.

We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (93)

Why Trust The Spruce Eats?

From baking pans, iron skillets, and griddles, to the Lodge Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven she tested for this roundup, Donna Currie knows a good cast iron product when she sees one. The Spruce Eats writer is a self-proclaimed lover of all things cast iron: "I’ve had cast-iron skillets knocking around in my kitchen for decades, acquiring seasoning and becoming beautifully nonstick," she says.

This piece was updated with Lab testing and more insights by Bernadette Machard de Gramont, an LA-based writer who specializes in global food and wine content. She researches and tests a variety of cookware, bakeware, and wine tools, and interviews field experts for their insight.

The 7 Best Roasting Pans of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

We Tested 29 Dutch Ovens—Here are the Best for Braising and Baking (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner

Last Updated:

Views: 6298

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner

Birthday: 1994-06-25

Address: Suite 153 582 Lubowitz Walks, Port Alfredoborough, IN 72879-2838

Phone: +128413562823324

Job: IT Strategist

Hobby: Video gaming, Basketball, Web surfing, Book restoration, Jogging, Shooting, Fishing

Introduction: My name is Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner, I am a zany, graceful, talented, witty, determined, shiny, enchanting person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.